Imagine that you’re walking home as twilight descends. You’re tired after spending a day caring for a sick neighbor. And you’ve made the mistake of staying too late. The walk home is three miles long. Darkness descends.
You’ve walked through a stand of trees and are about to cross a meadow and enter a forest. The gray sky lifts your gaze to a supernatural vision. Four hands hold a sheet over a corpse. You hear a voice saying, “The Lord have mercy on the people. The Lord have mercy on the people. The Lord have mercy on the people.”
That is the situation Harriet Prescott Spofford sets up in her 1860 short story “Circumstance.” Spofford based her work on an incident that happened to her great-grandmother during America’s pioneer days.
The story is worth a look in these days of turmoil.
Spofford’s story features an unnamed protagonist–an everywoman walking metaphorically through life where she faces the challenges of ministry, peril, and darkness to emerge into a new day.
The woman in the story shakes off her vision. She is not prone to fear. But fear soon overcomes her when a panther–an Indian Devil, in Spofford’s words–grabs her, hoists her into a tree, and makes clear his intentions to enjoy her as a meal.
Instinctively, she yells. The animal pauses. She calls to her husband realizing he is too far away to help. But she notices that her vocalizing has caused the panther to stop chewing on her.
She begins to sing, regaling the panther with a range of songs through the night. The songs begin close to home. She thinks of her husband, her infant in the cradle, starting with nursery and dance tunes.
But soon the music shifts to that of a Methodist hymnal. That’s significant because John Wesley organized his song collection differently from other hymnals.
Most church songbooks follow the Church calendar. Wesley’s follows the structure of The Pilgrim’s Progress, John Bunyan’s account of an everyman’s journey from conviction to confession to Christian journey, ultimately to the Celestial City–Heaven.
The woman sings through the night. She’s exhausted. She’s in pain. As morning dawns, her voice begins to fail. She hears noises she at first thinks an animal is making. But she comes to realize they are human steps.
Her husband, having become concerned about her extended absence, arrives carrying their child and his musket. She continues to sing with a raspy voice.
He takes aim at the cat but can’t get a clear shot. Her voice continues to falter.
It’s only when she stops, when she can longer connect words and melody, that the animal pauses. He’s enjoying the music and wants it to continue.
The cat shifts his position. The man shoots. She is saved.
Spofford brings a clear picture of salvation–not by our own work. The woman’s own work only delays inevitable death. His work after hers ends rescues her.
It’s a wonderful story, and the man and woman think it’s ended. It has not. (Full spoiler ahead.)
The man carries the child and the weapon. He carries the future and the means of protection.
His wife follows as they head home. He reaches the top of a hill as she notices a footprint on the ground. As she rises to stand next to him, they survey the results of an attack that annihilated their community.
All who stayed behind in what they thought was a safe place are dead. All that remains are smoldering cabins.
The attack of the devil animal in the dark was hard and horrible. But the attack was a gift that saved their lives.
We live in a time where things look bleak. It’s dark outside. Many of us feel under attack.
A new day will come on this shore or on the other. We can have hope. Perhaps the panther that wants to eat us is, in reality, a means of protection.
We don’t know what is happening on the other side of a hill where we thought it was safe.
We can trust the providential God who leads us into the woods. And back out again.
22 Replies to “The Providence of a “Circumstance””
What comfort we can feel when remembering that even in dark times, God is with us. We are not alone. We are His.
Amen, Melissa. Thanks and God bless!
Wow – what a powerful analogy!
This is a picture that will stay with me through our perilous times.
I hope so–for you and for me, Ava. Thanks and God bless!
Let me start by saying, “WOW.” What a great story (I have not read the book) and so spot-on for our world today. We don’t understand what the Lord is doing because His ways are higher than our ways. We must trust Him as He saves us from the unknown event over the hill. Thanks for sharing this Nancy. Great post.
Thank you, Yvonne. It was my message to students today. I love that story. God bless!
No matter how dark, we always have hope. Thanks for sharing the story.
Thank you, Barbara. God bless!
Hallelujah and Maranatha Amen-Amein Nancy!!
Thank you, Kristi Ann. God bless!
Wow – I got shivers at this. Your words hit home: “The attack of the devil animal in the dark was hard and horrible. But the attack was a gift that saved their lives.” Sometimes we lament the current pain we are in. Sometimes we cannot see beyond it and appreciate it. But sometimes, that pain brings a profound gift, whether a lesson, sometimes that staves off worse pain, even salvation in Christ.
It’s so true, Jessica. God love us. He’s not out to get us. He wants what’s good for us. Thanks and God bless!
Nancy, what a unique way to share a powerful message of truth. Thank you.
Thank you, Jeannie. God bless!
What an amazing story! And so appropriate for the season we are in as we struggle to make sense of what is happening in our country. But as you remind us, Nancy, our Protector–our God–is in control. Our task is to trust Him, no matter how dark the path or the dangers which overtake us. Thank you for sharing this inspiring and thought provoking message.
Thank you, Katherine. It’s a story I love to revisit since I first read it give or take 30 years ago. God bless!
What a powerful piece, Nancy! My husband I were talking about this very reality on our walk today, a situation where the current reality seems awful, but then down the road you discover that the awful situation spared you from the even more horrendous outcome. Had we a choice, we wouldn’t choose either, and yet God is sovereign. He works our circumstances together to produce good in our lives, the outcome that will bring us even closer to him.
This gives me peace as I consider the dismal state of our nation at this juncture. I hope and pray for the Lord to lead us, as a nation, to genuine relationship with him and that he will use all of the trying events he has allowed to come our way in 2020 and still in 2021 to accomplish it.
Those trying events were part of why I thought it was important to retell this story. Thanks, Melinda. God bless!
Wow. Nancy, thank you for sharing this word of inspiration and courage in our Savior during these dark times. It was just the message I needed today.
Thank you, Melissa. I needed it too. God bless!
Soul-stirring piece, Nancy! I didn’t even mind the spoiler as it hit home the spiritual treasure written between the lines!
Thank you, Karen. It’s a fabulous story–with roots in reality and truth. God bless!